605 Prospect Drive

~1-acre lot in Prospect with seller-included "Hill Residence" plans. Listed $650K; last sold $445K (2021).

Seller’s 3D rendering of the Hill Residence from the northwest: glass gable, decks, and the walkout lower level
Hill Residence from the northwest — seller’s rendering, sheet A-501. Design as drawn, not yet built or approved.
List price
$650,000
Plans included unverified · medium
All-in, base plan (mid)
$7.69M
Range $5.74M – $10.24M unverified · low
All-in, lock-off (mid)
$7.83M
Lock-off premium ≈ $130K unverified · low
Per family, base (mid)
$1.08M equity
$21,526/mo all-in (50% share) unverified · low
Lock-off rental (mid)
$1,961/mo
covers 4% of the lock-off plan's monthly all-in; premium payback 5.5 yrs unverified · low

Verdict 2026-09-19

undecided

Scorecard

Weighted 3.1 / 5 across 5 of 6 criteria
CriterionScoreWeightWhy
Value vs comps●●●○○2Asking is well above the 2021 sale, partly explained by the included plans. No Prospect lot comps pulled yet.
Cost vs budgetnot scored3The mid all-in (see the Summary cards) is large for a second home, but there is no agreed ceiling to score it against.Blocked: Family budget ceiling not agreed.
Ski / location●●●●○2Prospect sits between the Prospect and Gold Link lifts with ski bridges. Exact lot and walk-to-lift distance unknown.
Rental offset●●○○○1Lock-off net income covers a small share of the lock-off plan's monthly all-in at mid (see the Rental page). Prospect covenants allow STR/lock-off (confirmed 2026-09-19). A further 5% excise on residential STRs is on the 2026 Mt. CB ballot.
Risk from unknowns●●●○○2Covenant/STR ban risk is closed. Still open: plan phase, design-review history, tap status, metro-district mills, and builder pricing (see Risks & DD).
Timeline●●●○○1From a hypothetical October 2026 closing, the mid case finishes in November 2028, in time for the 2028–29 ski season. The unfavorable case finishes in December 2029 after an excavation-blackout slip (see the Timeline page).

Scores are the families' working judgment as of 2026-09-19, not measurements. Higher is better on every row, including risk.

Top open risks full tracker

  1. No agreed family budget ceiling (score 20/25) — Agree an all-in ceiling and an equity ceiling per family.
  2. Builder pricing above the mid $/sf (score 16/25) — Get rough $/sf and schedule from two or three Gunnison Valley GCs.
  3. Wildfire-zone insurance unavailable or far above estimate (score 9/25) — Get an indicative quote from a high-value carrier on the plan set.

See the build cost breakdown → · Rental analysis → · What-if calculator →